Flipr
arrow_backAll posts
DATA ANALYSISNovember 1, 2026
· 7 min read· Flipr Team

Lugia BREAK PSA 10 Prices Doubled After We Said Sell Raw

We told readers to sell Lugia BREAK raw in September. The PSA 10 median went from $1,000 to $1,818. Here is that call and seven others, scored.

Lugia BREAK PSA 10 Prices Doubled After We Said Sell Raw

On September 4 we looked at Lugia BREAK, decided the run was sympathy demand off a rumored Greninja BREAK reprint, and told readers to sell raw copies into the $43 to $45 board instead of mailing one to PSA. Greninja BREAK did get reprinted. It shipped in the 30th Celebration Classic Collection on September 16, and it sells for $11.12 today. Lugia BREAK went up anyway.

Eight of our calls came due for review this week, so we pulled a current price on every one of them. Five played out, one landed on a coin flip, and two were wrong, including that one.

The scorecard

Every "now" figure below was pulled on November 2, 2026. Graded prices come from PriceCharting's grade tables and its dated sold listings. Raw prices come from TCGplayer, checked against the live listing board.

Card What we said Then Now Verdict
Lugia BREAK #79 Sell raw, skip the queue (Sep 4) Raw $44.63, PSA 10 $793 Raw $49.51, PSA 10 $1,809 Wrong
Umbreon V #189 Express pays for itself (Aug 24) PSA 10 $1,043.73 PSA 10 $999.50 Wrong
Umbreon VMAX #215 Slabs fall faster than raw (Aug 31) 2.00 times raw 2.00 times raw Dead heat
Rayquaza Gold Star #107 A $1M sale lifts nothing (Sep 4) Grade 9 $82,638 Grade 9 $84,138 Correct
Ash-Greninja EX #XY133 Grade it, price the PSA 9 (Aug 3) PSA 10 $9,945 PSA 10 $7,580 Correct
Mew ex Futuristic Rare #158 Falls from day one (Sep 17) $157.94 $44.85 Correct
Alolan Vulpix V promo #033 Keeps climbing (Sep 17) $20.91 $24.13 Correct
Jirachi ex #155 The bounce gives back (Sep 29) $97.04 $37.30 Correct

Lugia BREAK PSA 10 prices went from $1,000 to $1,818

The slab tape is what makes this one hurt. PriceCharting's dated sold listings show eleven PSA 10 Lugia BREAK sales through September, from the 11th to the 29th, with a median of $1,000. In October there were thirteen more, running from $1,100 up to $4,495, with a median of $1,818.18. Two copies sold on November 2 at $1,525.00 and $1,425.00, so it has cooled off the October high and is still worth about half again what it was when we said to sell.

The raw card did not give anything back either. TCGplayer's market price is $49.51 today against $44.63 on September 4. We checked the live board rather than trusting the aggregate, and the cheapest Near Mint English copy costs $51.01 delivered, from sixteen Near Mint English listings with no foreign prints mixed in. In September the cheapest delivered copy was $43.00.

Worth flagging: PriceCharting's ungraded figure for this card reads $25.00 right now, which would have told us raw prices fell 11 percent while the live board shows them rising. The aggregate lags badly on a card that moves quickly, and scoring this off PriceCharting alone would have handed us a verdict of correct on a call we lost.

Supply explains the rest. PSA has graded 1,815 copies of Lugia BREAK in total and 537 of them are 10s, up from 524 two months ago. That is thirteen new gem copies against a price that doubled. The 29.6 percent lifetime gem rate was in our original post, and so was the arithmetic showing the submission worked. We talked ourselves out of it on the lock up time, not the numbers.

The honest version of what we got wrong: we assumed attention on BREAK cards would fade once 30th Celebration was in people's hands. Instead the reprint introduced the mechanic to a new wave of collectors, and the one BREAK card that was never going to be reprinted caught that demand with its print run already fixed. We had the mechanism right in the original post and still read the direction backwards.

Is PSA Express worth it? Not on the card we picked

On August 24 we argued for paying up for Express and built the call around Umbreon V #189. The claim was testable: a modern chase card worth about $1,000 in a PSA 10 would shed more than the $69.01 Express premium over the extra ten weeks the Regular queue added. That put the line at $974.72.

The card came in at $975.00. That is the median of 23 PSA 10 sales between October 22 and November 2, and it misses our own threshold by 28 cents. PriceCharting's grade table reads $999.50. Either way the price test resolved nothing, because we set the line so close to the current price that the answer was always going to be noise.

The recommendation still failed, for a reason the threshold could not see. PSA repriced the service underneath us. Reading psacard.com/pricing today, Express costs $199.00 and Priority costs $79.99, so the premium is $119.01 rather than the $69.01 we measured in August. The queues moved too: Priority now quotes 50 to 60 business days and Express quotes 20 to 30, so Express buys back about 30 business days instead of 50. It costs 72 percent more to save 40 percent less time. On a card that lost $44 over ten weeks, that is not close.

The lesson is not about Umbreon. When a call is about whether a service is worth paying for, the service's own price and speed are variables, and we only re-read the card. Our newer Standard versus Priority breakdown has the same shape of risk, so we will be re-reading the fee page at every review from now on, not just the comps.

Evolving Skies slabs and raw copies fell together

On August 31 we called the graded copies the weaker side of Evolving Skies and said Umbreon VMAX #215 would keep losing ground against its own raw price. The falsification line was simple: wrong if the PSA 10 was worth more than 2.00 times a raw copy at review.

It is worth 2.0026 times a raw copy. The slab fell from $4,200 to $3,550 and the raw copy fell from $2,095.75 to $1,772.72, both down about 15 percent, moving together the whole way. Our mechanism was wrong and the practical advice was right, which is the most awkward kind of half credit. Anyone who priced a November submission off the August PSA 10 overpaid by $650.

PSA added 407 grades to that card over the two months and the PSA 10 population now sits at 21,744 out of 31,453 graded, so supply did keep growing, it simply pushed on the raw copies and the slabs at the same rate.

The five that worked

Three of the five were 30th Celebration cards falling after launch, which is the easiest call in the hobby and we will not pretend otherwise. Mew ex Futuristic Rare went from $157.94 on its first real trading day to $44.85. Jirachi ex #155 went from $97.04 to $37.30. Both landed inside the band we expected.

The other two are the ones we are actually pleased with. We said the $1.02 million Rayquaza Gold Star sale in August would not lift ordinary copies, and ten weeks later Grade 9 copies are $84,137.50 against $82,637.50 and a blended ungraded copy is $9,394.74, still under the $10,500 line we drew. On Ash-Greninja EX we said to grade it but to work out the profit off the PSA 9 rather than the thin PSA 10. The PSA 10 fell 24 percent to $7,580.36 while the PSA 9 rose to $1,057.12, so a submission that only ever counted on the 9 is still in good shape.

What we are changing

Three things go into how we score from here. Read the fee page at review, not just the card, because PSA moves its own prices faster than most of these cards move. Check the live listing board before trusting any aggregate raw price, since PriceCharting had Lugia BREAK's raw copies falling while the cheapest real copy was going up. And stop setting thresholds within a few percent of today's price, because two of these eight landed inside the margin and taught us nothing.

The ledger behind this post holds 100 calls with 35 still open, and the running record is 35 correct, 19 partly and 11 wrong. It is the same record the profit math in the Flipr app gets checked against, so a correction here lands in both places. The next batch comes due in early December.

#predictions#psa-10#grading-economics#market-timing

Want to flip smarter, not harder?

Flipr's free toolkit surfaces the most profitable cards to grade and the spreads to arbitrage, refreshed every 30 minutes. Twelve tools, zero subscriptions.

Open Flipr
KEEP READING

More on PSA flipping