Mudkip Gold Star PSA 9s Sold for $45,044 This Week, and 30th Celebration Charizard Bounced 22%
Three Mudkip Gold Star PSA 9s sold between $45,044 and $47,100 in eight days while raw copies stayed near $3,000. Classic Collection Charizard rose 22%.

Collectors on r/PokeInvesting spent the week posting five-figure Gold Star sales at each other: a Regice at $65,000, a Raikou at $70,000, a PSA 1 Torchic at $16,200. The card underneath all that noise is a 2004 Mudkip, and its graded copies have nearly tripled since August while raw copies have gone nowhere. On the other end of the hobby, the 30th Celebration Classic Collection stopped falling and bounced, with the Base Set Charizard reprint up 22% in eight days.
What's hot: Mudkip Gold Star (EX Team Rocket Returns #107)
Mudkip Gold Star, 107/109 from EX Team Rocket Returns, illustrated by Masakazu Fukuda in 2004, has sold three times as a PSA 9 in the last eight days. The tape reads $45,300 on October 15, $47,100 on October 16, and $45,044 on October 22. One more went at $50,200 on September 24. Back in July a BGS 9 copy sold for $14,999.99, and on August 31 a CGC 9 went for $12,999, so the whole 9 tier has roughly tripled in under three months.
The grade ladder on PriceCharting, read October 22, runs $3,009.31 ungraded, $9,847.13 at Grade 7, $23,864.88 at Grade 8, $35,382.61 at Grade 9, $38,921.00 at Grade 9.5 and $42,459.00 at PSA 10. A CGC 10 sold for $108,988 on October 5.
Look at where the move actually happened. The monthly Grade 9 figure went $12,817.58 in August, $21,175 in September, $35,382.61 in October. Over the same three months the ungraded figure went $2,815.13, then $3,400, then $3,009.31, which is noise on a card that trades a handful of times a month. Raw copies sold for $4,000 on October 3 and $2,500 on October 18. A year ago, in October 2025, a raw copy was worth about $2,088.77 and a Grade 9 about $10,000, so the gap between the two has gone from roughly 5x to roughly 12x in twelve months.
The mechanism is the population report, not the hype. The BetterPop mirror of PSA's data, dated September 30, shows 1,421 English copies graded in the card's entire history, with 42 PSA 10s, 284 PSA 9s and 293 PSA 8s. That is a 3.0% gem rate, the lowest we have written about on this blog. Three of the 284 PSA 9s in existence changed hands in eight days, and that is enough to move a price when there are only 284 of them.
Its two shelfmates moved with it. Torchic Gold Star #108 reads $3,324.42 raw against a $62,625.62 Grade 9, and Treecko Gold Star #109 reads $3,365.22 raw against a $114,000 PSA 10. The whole Hoenn starter trio is doing the same thing: the slabs are being repriced and the cardboard is not.
The flipper's angle. This card inverts everything we normally say about the gap between a PSA 9 and a PSA 10. On a modern chase card the 9 is the booby prize. Here a PSA 7 sold for $16,000 on September 2 and $12,100 the day before, against a raw copy worth about $3,000, so every grade above 6 pays. That makes submitting sound obvious, and it is not, for two reasons. PSA's upcharge rule prices your submission off what the card is worth after grading, so a copy that comes back a 9 lands in a service tier that costs real money, and you owe that fee whether it grades or not. The bigger problem is the one we just showed you: the PSA 8 has already turned. Those copies sold at $32,100 and $31,100 on October 5, then $27,600 and $27,100 on October 11 and 12, then $26,000 and $25,279.50 on October 19. That is about 20% off the peak in two weeks, on the tier directly below the one still printing records. Lower grades turning first is usually what profit taking looks like before it reaches the top of the ladder.
If you own a raw Mudkip Gold Star, the honest read is that holding it raw has been the worst of the three options this year and submitting it today means waiting out a PSA queue while the tier below your target grade is already sliding. We would not buy one at $3,000 to grade. We would hold a slab we already owned.
Our call: on December 22, 2026 the PriceCharting Grade 8 figure for Mudkip Gold Star #107 will be below today's $23,864.88, because the October sales on that tier already fell about 20% from their own peak. We will grade this right or wrong in a future post. We are naming a direction and a reason, not a landing price, because an attention-driven run has nothing holding it up at any particular level.
Biggest gainer: Charizard (30th Celebration Classic Collection #4/102)

Charizard 4/102 from the 30th Celebration Classic Collection, the Base Set reprint carrying the Pikachu 30 stamp, went from a $137.35 TCGplayer market price on October 14 to $167.61 on October 22. That is up 22.0% in eight days, and about $30 in cash.
The shape matters more than the percentage. This card was at $207.72 on September 29, slid to a $134.82 bottom on October 17, and has climbed every reading since. The listing floor moved with it, from $133.45 on October 17 to $173.00 on October 22, which means the cheap copies genuinely cleared rather than the average being dragged by a single rich sale. We walked the live board on October 22 and found 45 listings, 43 of them Near Mint English, 47 copies, with the cheapest delivered copy at $149.99 from PokeTN TCG. You can still buy one for less than the published market price.
It is not just Charizard. Across the whole Classic Collection the eight-day read is 19 products up against 11 down. Mew VMAX 114/264 led at 27.7%, going from $18.48 to $23.60 on a board of 60 Near Mint English listings and 69 copies with a $21.74 floor. Scizor ex and Greninja BREAK both added 20.6%, Palkia LV.X 18.4%, and Lugia 149/147 climbed from $178.65 to $197.11. Arceus VSTAR, the card we covered last week, added another 17.6%.
Now the part that keeps this honest. Stretch the window to thirty days and the same set reads 6 up against 24 down. Three weeks ago we wrote that thirteen of the set's fourteen Illustration Rares had fallen in a single week, and nothing has happened since to reverse that. This is a bounce inside a decline, and the bounce came from a listing floor that got picked clean, not from a wave of new buyers.
The flipper's angle. Do not grade this one yet. PSA has six English copies of Charizard 4/102 on record as of October 1, all six of them PSA 10, which tells you nothing useful about the gem rate. The set launched September 16 and PSA's queue runs long enough that the first real submission wave has not come back. When it does, several thousand slabs will land at once and reprice the graded side, which is exactly what happened to Mega Greninja ex after Chaos Rising. Raw at $149.99 delivered is a fine price if you want the card. It is a coin flip if you want the slab.
Our call: on December 1, 2026 the TCGplayer market price for Charizard 4/102 will be below today's $167.61, because the set is still 24 down against 6 up over thirty days and the first graded supply arrives in that window. Wrong if it is flat or higher.
Scoring last quarter's calls
Four predictions came due this week and we pulled live prices on all four.
Gladion's Final Battle #118, called August 22. Correct. We said attention had spiked and the price had not, and that the TCGplayer market would be below $32.72 by October 21. It read $22.98 that day, down 29.8%, and $22.19 on October 22.
30th Celebration ex Boxes, called September 19. Correct. Both were still falling four days after release and we said both would be cheaper by October 20. Reading the boards this week, the Greninja ex Box floor went from $58.93 to $55.90 and the Sylveon ex Box from $64.89 to $59.00.
Greninja BREAK #41, called July 23. Partly. The structural half held and then some: the PSA 10 was 50x the ungraded price at the call and is about 83x now, at $1,236.29 against $14.95, and the Grade 9 at $88.74 still does not clear a submission. The half we got wrong was the level. We said raw would hold a band of roughly $18 to $32 and it sits at $14.95. That is the fifth call in a row where we got the direction right and a named price level broke, which is why we stopped naming them.
Fezandipiti ex, called September 18. Partly. We said the Ascended Heroes printing would be under $4.41 by October 20 and it was, at $4.37. We also said the Shrouded Fable printing would overtake it, and it did not, sitting at $3.54 that day with a $4.19 delivered floor today against Ascended Heroes at $4.39.
That card earned one more lesson this week. Our mover list shows Fezandipiti ex up 91.3% over eight days, from $4.38 to $8.38, which would have made it this week's gainer by a mile. The live board says otherwise: 190 Near Mint English listings, 626 copies, and a cheapest delivered price of $4.39. Nothing about the card changed, the published average did. Two Prize Pack cards failed the same check, with Pumpkaboo 076/203 showing a $31.34 market against a board of four copies starting at $80, and Rayquaza VMAX 111/203 quoting $595.99 with exactly one Near Mint English copy listed at $620.98. A price you cannot transact at is not a price.
What this week tells you
Both halves of this post are the same trade seen from opposite ends. Mudkip Gold Star has 284 PSA 9s in the world and a tape of three recent sales, so three buyers moved the number. Classic Collection Charizard has a 47 copy board and bounced the moment the cheap listings cleared. Thin supply is doing all the work on both, and thin supply cuts the other way just as fast, which is what the PSA 8 tier on the Mudkip has already started doing.
The concrete action: before you act on any card that shows up on a weekly gainers list, open its listing page and count the Near Mint English copies. If the answer is under about twenty, the percentage you just read is a description of one person's purchase, not of a market. Flipr runs that check automatically on every card it surfaces, and this week it is the difference between the three cards we wrote about and the four we threw out.
Want to flip smarter, not harder?
Flipr's free toolkit surfaces the most profitable cards to grade and the spreads to arbitrage, refreshed every 30 minutes. Twelve tools, zero subscriptions.
Open FliprMore on PSA flipping

Giratina Prism Star PSA 10s Sold for $9,999, and the 30th Celebration Zeraora Promo Rose 44%
Giratina Prism Star 58/156 gems at 17.3% and two PSA 10s sold near $9,999 in three weeks. The 30th Celebration Zeraora promo rose 44% to $23.92.

Latios Prism Star's PSA 10 Price Doubled to $1,400, and Classic Collection Arceus VSTAR Jumped 43%
Latios Prism Star PSA 10 prices went from $750 to $1,400 in a month while the raw card barely moved, and Classic Collection Arceus VSTAR rose 43%.

The Free Mewtwo Promo Is Selling for $14, and Armarouge's Stamped Promo Jumped 46% in a Week
Mewtwo 063/128 is free with a $15 purchase and resells near $14. The Armarouge What's Your Favorite stamp went from $42.01 to $61.19 in seven days.